Criminal Law Blog
Parole Conditions (Part 1)
On August 3, 2023, the New Jersey Supreme Court decided the case of Leander Williams v. New Jersey State Parole Board. The principal issue concerned whether the parole board could mandate participation in adult residential treatment program for inmates paroled under...
Warrantless Searches and Abandoned Property (Part 4)
Justice Noriega filed a dissenting opinion. He wrote that the majority expanded the previously narrow abandonment exception to New Jersey’s automatic standing rule by making abandonment synonymous with flight. In Justice Noriega’s view, it is a step backwards in New...
Warrantless Searches and Abandoned Property (Part 3)
Justice Solomon continued in relevant part: In Johnson, the Court held that the defendant had not surrendered his standing to challenge the search of a bag solely because he had disclaimed ownership, given that the bag was in an apartment with five occupants and could...
Warrantless Searches and Abandoned Property (Part 2)
The New Jersey Supreme Court majority continued in relevant part: While other officers chased and arrested defendant, one officer secured and searched the suitcase at the entrance of the station, revealing the contraband. Defendant was charged with possessory offenses...
Warrantless Searches and Abandoned Property (Part 1)
On January 17, 2024, the New Jersey Supreme Court decided the Essex County case of State v. Curtis Gartrell. The principal issue before the Court concerned whether the defendant had standing to challenge the search of property that the police searched without a...
Standing to Seek Megan’s Law Termination (Part 4)
The three-judge panel concluded with the following in relevant part: Each local system makes its own determinations about who is required to register, which crimes are registerable offenses, what information offenders must provide, and what consequences are inherent...
Standing to Seek Megan’s Law Termination (Part 3)
Judge Puglisi continued in relevant part: "SORNA classifies sex offenders into three risk tiers--Tiers I, II, and III--for registration and notification purposes, depending solely on the nature of the offense." Id. at 62 (citing 34 U.S.C. § 20911). "The offender's...
Standing to Seek Megan’s Law Termination (Part 2)
The Appellate Division continued in relevant part: J.R. relies heavily on his assertion that, regardless of his residency in another state, he nevertheless continues to have Megan's Law "status" in New Jersey. We reject this argument because there is no legal "status"...
Standing to Seek Megan’s Law Termination (Part 1)
On January 31, 2024, a three-judge appellate panel decided the Middlesex County case of IN the Matter of Registrant J.R. The principal issue before the Court under N.J.S.A. 2C:7-2 concerned whether the resident of another state had standing to seek termination of his...
Witness Tampering (Part 4)
The unanimous New Jersey Supreme Court concluded with the following in relevant part: Defendant urges us to dismiss the witness tampering charge with prejudice because "the evidence is insufficient" to allow a reasonable jury to conclude "that Hill knew that it was...