Drug Court Resentencings and the Sixth Amendment (Part 6)

by | Apr 20, 2020 | Blog, Criminal Law, Drug Crime, Monmouth County, New Jersey, Ocean County

The Appellate panel continued in relevant part: Under federal law, the period of incarceration and ensuing period of supervised release are deemed to be “distinct aspects” of punishment. United States v. Work, 409 F.3d 484, 489 (1st Cir. 2005). Accordingly, “courts routinely have held that the combined sentence of years of imprisonment plus years of supervised release may exceed the statutory maximum number of years of imprisonment authorized by the substantive statute applicable to the crime of conviction.” Ibid.

If defendant’s expansive interpretation of Apprendi were correct, the federal statutory scheme upheld in Work and revisited in Haymond would run afoul of the Sixth Amendment unless time spent on supervised release before revocation were treated the same as time spent in prison. However, § 3583(e)(3) expressly provides to the contrary that the new sentence following revocation of supervised release is imposed “without credit for time previously served on postrelease supervision.” It bears emphasis that the plurality made no mention of any constitutional concern with this statutory feature, even as the Court struck down a specific mandatory minimum sentencing provision of that statute on Apprendi grounds. The failure to allude to any constitutional problem with the statutory feature that treats time on supervised release so differently from time spent in prison is telling. In our view this confirms that the Court never contemplated that Apprendi principles might possibly extend to forms of punishment other than minimum and maximum terms of imprisonment.

We find further support for our conclusion that the Supreme Court never meant for Apprendi to apply to non-custodial forms of punishment in the plurality’s response to concerns expressed by the dissenting Justices. The dissent complained, “[t]he plurality opinion appears to have been carefully crafted for the purpose of laying the groundwork for later decisions of much broader scope.” 588 U.S. at __, 139 S. Ct. at 2386 (Alito, J., dissenting). The plurality responded to those concerns about the future expansion of the Apprendi doctrine, noting:

Besides, even if our opinion could be read to cast doubts on § 3583(e) and its consistency with Apprendi, the practical consequences of a holding to that effect would not come close to fulfilling the dissent’s apocalyptic prophecy. In most cases (including this one), combining a defendant’s initial and post-revocation sentences issued under § 3583(e) will not yield a term of imprisonment that exceeds the statutory maximum term of imprisonment the jury has authorized for the original crime of conviction. [588 U.S. __, 139 S. Ct. at 2384 (plurality opinion) (emphases added).]

Notably, in this pointed discussion of the potential breadth of Apprendi‘s reach, the plurality referred to the combination of two periods of incarceration, not to the combination of a period of incarceration and a period of supervised release when describing a composite sentence that might conceivably exceed the “statutory maximum.” The point simply is that even as the plurality and dissenting Justices argued vociferously about the prospects for expanding the Apprendi doctrine, no one raised the possibility of an expansion of the type and to the degree defendant urges us to accept in this appeal. In sum, we read the Haymond plurality and dissenting opinions to be consistent with our conclusion that Apprendi, Blakely, Alleyne, and Ring focus exclusively on prison sentences and simply do not apply to non-custodial probationary sentences.

A counter to the panel’s analysis here is that courts are not supposed to reach constitutional issues unless they are required to in deciding the case. That would explain why the Haymond Court did not address Apprendi’s application to non-custodial sentences.

Excellent rating
Based on 287 reviews
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Fred was a excellent choice for my case, whatever he told on the first call exactly what happened in courtroom, very professional/ Down to earth, great in communication he reply’s no matter what time of the day or night it is. Very impresses with him and I finally found my go to guy for every legal need.
Sam S
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
I recently found myself facing legal issues for the first time, and it was a daunting experience. My tests showed some prescribed medication, which I believed I was legally allowed to drive with. A friend recommended that I seek an attorney, and I came across Fred Sisto, who had outstanding 5-star reviews. From the moment I reached out to him, I felt a sense of relief. Unlike other attorneys I spoke with, who were quick to quote fees, Fred took the time to educate me about my situation and what steps I should take if anything like this happened again. His genuine concern and thorough approach made it clear he was the right attorney for me. I retained him the very next day. What impressed me even more was Fred’s dedication to saving me money wherever possible. His expertise and strategic guidance paid off immensely—my case was dismissed without any fines! I can’t thank Fred enough for his support and professionalism. If you’re looking for a criminal lawyer, look no further—Fred Sisto is your guy!
Luda P
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
2 👍🏻👍🏻 up
Cc
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
For the people. For the little guy My legal bully
Glennlykesmusic
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Spot on, 100%
Earl M
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Me Sisto went above and beyond for my case I couldn’t be happier with the outcome. If you’re looking for someone to represent you Mr Sisto will knock it out of the park for you. Thank you Thank you Thank You!
Tony L
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Very knowledgeable with expungement!!! Thanks again!!!
Nicole B
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Helped with my issues timely manner and continued constant communication to make sure I was aware of any changes or issues that arose.
Whick 3
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Fred was incredibly helpful during a very stressful time. Even during a pandemic he was fast at responding to any and all questions or problems that I had. He went above and beyond to make sure that I was happy with my results and that my case was being handled properly all the way through. Highly recommend this office!
Toni V
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
I follow this link on a regular basis. I pass on the locations to friends in the hope that they will realize that the police, whether right or wrong, are serious about enforcement. A DUI can be a career ending event and will cost a fortune. Think before you drink and drjve.
Stephen M