The Persistent Offender Statute and Jury Determinations (Part 3)

by | Jul 10, 2025 | Blog, Criminal Law, Monmouth County, New Jersey, Ocean County

The Appellate Division concluded with the following in relevant part: While we are mindful of the administrative burdens that will result from remanding a potentially large number of pipeline cases for new jury trials, we are not prepared to hold that the defendants in pipeline case are entitled to less vigorous protection of their Fifth and Sixth Amendment rights than defendants whose crimes, indictments, or trials happen to occur after June 21, 2024. See Erlinger, 602 U.S. at 842 (“There is no efficiency exception to the Fifth and Sixth Amendments.”). The notion that there can be any such differentiated enforcement of the Erlinger rule would suggest that there is another de facto retroactivity option, namely partial or attenuated application of a rule to cases pending direct appeal. We are not familiar with any such permutation in New Jersey or federal retroactivity jurisprudence.

We do not mean to suggest that the harmless constitutional error doctrine can never apply to an Erlinger violation. But this is not a situation, for example, where a jury was provided with a flawed special verdict form or faulty instructions that were not objected to by the defense. Nor is this a situation where a jury was asked to make findings on some but not all the facts needed to establish the basis for an enhanced sentence. Here, none of the required findings that we have enumerated were submitted to a jury. The violation, in other words, amounts to a complete and absolute denial of the right to a jury trial on the sentence-enhancement determination.

For all these reasons, we decline to put the cart before the proverbial horse by excusing the failure to have a jury decide defendant’s extended-term eligibility on the grounds that affording a new jury trial on remand is highly unlikely to produce a different result than the one reached by the sentencing judge. Until the United States Supreme Court has an opportunity to more fully address the practical implications of the Erlinger rule, including whether and in what circumstances harmless error analysis is appropriate, we decline to disregard the uncontroverted constitutional violation that occurred in this case.

It will be interesting to see how the New Jersey Supreme Court handles this case on appeal. If it sees fit to consider the case, in light of the large number of pending pipeline cases, it might try to predict how the United States Supreme Court will address the practical implications of Erlinger.

Excellent rating
Based on 287 reviews
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
That’s my lawyer he’s the greatest
Donald J
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Very knowledgeable with expungement!!! Thanks again!!!
Nicole B
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Fred is a good lawyer, he is really young yet made me feel confident that my lawful rights were being protected, and investigated all avenues when there was potential they weren't. He is very knowledgeable, and offered great peace of mind in such a distressing situation. I always felt like he had my back throughout the whole process, supporting aspects to my case that didn't even fall within his scope. I would highly recommend Fred.
Amy L
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Great guy got me out of a lot of legal trouble highly recommended.
Frank S
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Fred sisto was an absolute life saver in my case I would recommend him to anyone in the future if needed.
Nelson C
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
My son was represented better than I could have ever imagined. His needs were put first and was treated as a friend rather than a number. His/ our opinions were valued and our doubts were always reassured. We couldn’t have asked for a better attorney out there!!! Thanks so much!
Danielle T
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Today my life was about to change! With great communication and excellent service he was able to create the impossible!! I am now able to continue to drive for a living!! I highly recommend his services and trust his judgment-HE KNOWS HIS STUFF!!! He saved my life and livelihood today! Mr.Frank Sisto is an absolutely amazing attorney! Thank you again I’ll never forget this day! God Bless
Edward J
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Fred's services has been more than exceptional. He provided updates on my case. He got me one of the best outcomes i could have asked for, and has represented me twice with amazing results. Fred can work his magic on your case just as he did for me
Chris K
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Deserved 5 star review. I got all my charges dismissed.
Mraz09222
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Mr. Fred Sisto handled a case regarding my business. He was always available to answer my calls directly and helped me with any questions I had. He also had the case dismissed before I was even able to make it to the court room! I know it can be difficult when finding an attorney but I know I made no mistake choosing the law offices of Frederick Sisto, I highly recommend him!!
Kari J