Warrantless Searches of Vehicles at Police Headquarters

by | Nov 6, 2025 | Blog, Criminal Law, Monmouth County, New Jersey, Ocean County

On July 30, 2025, the New Jersey Supreme Court decided the Salem County case of State v. Shawn Fenimore. The principal issue concerned the automobile exception to the warrant requirement under the New Jersey State Constitution.

Justice Wainer Apter wrote for the unanimous Court in relevant part: In this appeal, the Court considers whether the warrantless search of a car was consistent with the State Constitution when the car was parked in a State Police barracks parking lot; police had arrested the driver, removed the passenger, and obtained the keys; and the car was subject to imminent, mandatory impoundment. In response to a request for a statement regarding a harassment claim against him, defendant Shawn M. Fenimore arrived at the Woodstown State Police barracks shortly before 8:30 p.m. on June 2, 2021. New Jersey State Police Trooper Daniel Radetich interviewed defendant and administered three sobriety tests. Defendant failed two of them, and Radetich arrested defendant for driving while intoxicated (DWI) at approximately 8:57 p.m.

Radetich secured defendant to a holding cell bench and advised him that troopers would search his car. Radetich and four troopers found Nicholas Luzzo asleep in the passenger seat. One trooper escorted Luzzo into the police station. Troopers commenced a warrantless search of the car at 9:02 p.m. and found drugs, a loaded gun, and other evidence such as bolt cutters. Defendant was charged with possession offenses and moved to suppress the evidence discovered during the warrantless search of the car.

At the motion hearing, Radetich testified to the sequence of events described above. During cross examination, Radetich agreed that under John’s Law, troopers were required to impound defendant’s car after his arrest for DWI, “so, this car wasn’t going anywhere for at least twelve hours.” When asked why he did not secure a warrant, Radetich stated that “that’s our standard process. When you’re arrested for John’s Law, we have the right to a probable cause search of their vehicle.” The trial court denied the motion. Defendant pled guilty and appealed. The Appellate Division affirmed. The Court granted certification.

Under the circumstances presented here, the automobile exception to the warrant requirement did not apply and the police were required to obtain a warrant before searching the car. The automobile exception to the warrant requirement under the New Jersey Constitution is significantly more protective of motorists’ privacy interests than its federal counterpart. The Court has identified several rationales that support New Jersey’s automobile exception, including (1) the risk of the loss or destruction of evidence; (2) the unacceptable risk of serious bodily injury and death to officers, drivers, and passengers from prolonged encounters on the shoulder of a crowded highway; (3) the risk that motorists may feel compelled to consent to warrantless searches of their vehicles, which may be made on less than probable cause; (4) the recognition that, in certain circumstances, the privacy intrusion occasioned by a prompt search based on probable cause is not necessarily greater than a prolonged detention of the vehicle and its occupants while the police secure a warrant; and (5) the undue burden and impracticability of requiring police to post a special police detail to guard the immobilized automobile while pursuing a warrant.

Under “John’s Law,” when a person has been arrested for DWI, law enforcement “shall impound the vehicle that the person was operating at the time of arrest” “for a period of 12 hours after the time of arrest.” N.J.S.A. 39:4-50.23. In State v. Witt, the Court explicitly “parted from federal jurisprudence that allows a police officer to conduct a warrantless search at headquarters merely because he could have done so on the side of the road.” It expressly noted that “whatever inherent exigency justifies a warrantless search at the scene certainly cannot justify the failure to secure a warrant after towing and impounding the car at headquarters when it is practicable to do so.” And it specifically concluded that, going forward, New Jersey’s “automobile exception” would be limited “to on-scene warrantless searches.” Here, there was no “on-scene search”: the car was searched in a police barracks parking lot, not on the scene of a motor vehicle stop or any other incident. And the facts make clear there was no other “inherent exigency” to “justify a warrantless search under the automobile exception.” Further, none of the rationales the Court has identified to support New Jersey’s more limited automobile exception apply to the factual setting of this case. Therefore, the warrant requirement established by the State Constitution remained.

The State likely argued that in this case, the state police barracks was “on scene.” The Court’s holding indicates that the “on scene” phrase used in Witt and its progeny referred to the vehicle’s location before it was brought to headquarters. In the very rare case that the defendant brings his vehicle to headquarters before his arrest, the vehicle’s location triggers the warrant requirement.

Excellent rating
Based on 287 reviews
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Very informative.
Patrick S
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Fred was excellent and helped my son deal with a issue in PPB, despite being a long distance away. He is very thorough and knows how to navigate the ins and outs of the local legal waters.
Bruces
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Called back within 10 minutes,very easy to talk to. Not judgmental at all. I am hopeful about the outcome.
Colleen H
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Very good
Nazario B
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Fred Sisto is an excellent attorney who works diligently and thoroughly to support, advise, and guide you through your legal difficulties. He is down-to-earth, advises you well, and his cost is comparable and well-worth it based on the service and expertise that he provides. Fred was able to get me the best possible outcome for my situation based on the possibilities and he was direct and honest with me throughout the process. John McDonnell
John M
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Best criminal defense lawyer in ocean county!!
Austin A
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
I wholeheartedly recommend the legal services of Frederick Sisto. Mr. Sisto brings with him a wealth of knowledge, experience, and professionalism - qualities that make him highly effective at providing legal counsel.
John D
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Fred is extremely knowledgeable and so helpful. I would recommend him to anyone. He really goes above and beyond. He cares about his work and his clients.
Kevin M
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Antes que todo le doy las gracias señor Frederick P Sisto por representarme legalmente es usted un excelente abogado que habla con la verdad desde el principio es usted un abogado profesional que que sabe bien lo que hace ante los juzgados sin importar mi estatus legal en este país me represento con respeto y sobre todo muy profesionalmente y pudo hacer q bajaran mi delito de segundo grado a tercer grado y lo mejor que no permitió que me dieran tempo en carcel mi familia y yo estamos muy agradecidos con usted Puedo recomendar al señor abogado Frederick P Sisto como un excelente abogado y sin duda COMO UNO DE LOS MEJORES DEL ESTADO DE NEW JERSEY First of all I thank you Mister Frederick P Sisto for representing me legally you're an excellent lawyer who speaks to the truth from the beginning you are a professional lawyer who knows well what you do before the courts regardless of my legal status in this P Country I represent with respect and especially very professionally and could make Q lower my second-degree offense to third grade and the best I did not allow me to give tempo in jail my family and I are very grateful to you I can recommend Mr. Freder Attorney Ick P Sisto as an excellent lawyer and certainly as one of the best in the state of NEW JERSEY
Raul F
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Fred is a fantastic attorney who is very informative, knows the system well, and is very thorough.
Bob V