Fred Sisto | Criminal Attorney | Ocean and Monmouth County

Call Us Today
732-898-3232

  • Home
  • Criminal Defense Services
    ▼
    • Drug Crimes
      ▼
      • Drug Manufacturing
      • Intent to Distribute Narcotics
      • Prescription Drug Crimes
      • Leader of Narcotics Trafficking Network
    • Weapons Charges
      ▼
      • Prohibited Weapons and Devices
      • Manufacture, Transport, etc. of Weapons
      • Illegal Possession of a Gun
      • Possession of Weapons for Unlawful Purposes
    • Expungements
    • Theft Attorney
    • Violent Crimes
      ▼
      • Robbery/Burglary
      • Manslaughter
      • Extortion
      • Assault
      • Sexual Offenses
    • Arson
    • DUI / DWI
      ▼
      • Alcohol DUI
      • Drug DUI
      • Refusing a Breath Test
    • Driving with A Suspended License
    • Property Forfeiture
    • Anti-Drug Profiteering
    • Juvenile Delinquency
  • Español / Spanish Speaking Attorney
  • About
    ▼
    • Testimonials
    • Defending Cases In
      ▼
      • Monmouth County
      • Ocean County
  • Blog
  • Contact
    ▼
    • Receive a Call From Fred
  • DUI Checkpoint Alerts
  • Results
  • Payment Options
  • Home
  • Criminal Defense Services
    • Drug Crimes
      • Drug Manufacturing
      • Intent to Distribute Narcotics
      • Prescription Drug Crimes
      • Leader of Narcotics Trafficking Network
    • Weapons Charges
      • Prohibited Weapons and Devices
      • Manufacture, Transport, etc. of Weapons
      • Illegal Possession of a Gun
      • Possession of Weapons for Unlawful Purposes
    • Expungements
    • Theft Attorney
    • Violent Crimes
      • Robbery/Burglary
      • Manslaughter
      • Extortion
      • Assault
      • Sexual Offenses
    • Arson
    • DUI / DWI
      • Alcohol DUI
      • Drug DUI
      • Refusing a Breath Test
    • Driving with A Suspended License
    • Property Forfeiture
    • Anti-Drug Profiteering
    • Juvenile Delinquency
  • Español / Spanish Speaking Attorney
  • About
    • Testimonials
    • Defending Cases In
      • Monmouth County
      • Ocean County
  • Blog
  • Contact
    • Receive a Call From Fred
  • DUI Checkpoint Alerts
  • Results
  • Payment Options
Home >> Robbery and Lesser-Included Offenses (Part 1)

May 24, 2021 by Fred Sisto

Robbery and Lesser-Included Offenses (Part 1)

On March 22, 2021, the New Jersey Supreme Court decided the Mercer County case of State v. Andrea Dunbrack. The principal issue under N.J.S.A. 2C:15-1 was whether under the circumstances of the robbery case a lesser-included theft charge was required to be presented to the jury.

Justice Pierre-Louis, my Rutgers Law School classmate, wrote for the unanimous Court in relevant part: Having established the proper standard, we must determine whether the facts of this case jumped off the page such that the trial judge should have given the theft charge sua sponte. As detailed at length above, police arrived on the scene to find the victim on the ground, verbally unresponsive, in the fetal position, naked, bloodied, and burned by a small fire still ablaze nearby. His clothes were strewn about on the ground and on the front passenger seat of Dunbrack’s car, along with his passport, wallet, and money. A gun stained with the victim’s blood lay on the driver’s seat, and police later retrieved another gun on Dunbrack’s person when they searched her. Rodriguez fled as police approached and police later arrested him with the victim’s cell phone in his pocket. The victim testified that he thought defendants were going to kill him and that he feared for his life. Those facts, quite frankly, do not jump off the page as the basis for a charge of theft. And for the reasons we will discuss, even Dunbrack’s version of events do not support that charge.

Similar to Cassady, it is hard to consider the facts in this case — as presented by either side — as obviously indicating that a theft, as opposed to robbery, might have occurred. The idea that the facts of this case “jump off the page” as theft and therefore required the trial court to sua sponte charge theft as a lesser included offense is as implausible as the parallel argument found “absolutely ludicrous” in Cassady. For a theft charge to jump off the page, it would require the facts here to somehow support a finding that the victim was not threatened in any way and was not in fear of his life during the course of the taking of his belongings. The trial court was not obligated to sift through the record to formulate a scenario in which the defendants’ act of inflicting bodily injury on N.R. occurred separate and apart from defendants stealing N.R.’s belongings.

It can be a good defense strategy to argue that an assault later followed by an uncontemplated theft occurred instead of a robbery. This is because thefts and third-degree assaults are not NERA offenses. NERA (No Early Release Act) offenses require an imposition of an 85% parole disqualifier that does not apply to thefts or assaults that do not involve serious bodily injury.

Filed Under: Blog, Criminal Law, Monmouth County, New Jersey, Ocean County

Testimonials

Fred is a stickler for detail and communicates with clients very, very well. He is smart and astute. I would recommend him unconditionally.

Tom O   

I would highly recommend Mr. Sisto. He is very insightful and proficient, yet still down to Earth. Fred is great at communicating and breaking down the facts. But most importantly, he excels at getting results.

Bill K   

Thanks to Fred I have no criminal record whatsoever.

Luke A   

Great!!! , got my case handled in the exact manner that I was told and would recommend to everyone else in need of legal representation.

Raumelis R   
See More Testimonials

Recent Posts

  • Restraining Orders and Statutory Immunity (Part 2)
  • Restraining Orders and Statutory Immunity (Part 1)
  • Mistrials and Double Jeopardy (Part 4)
  • Mistrials and Double Jeopardy (Part 3)
  • Mistrials and Double Jeopardy (Part 2)
  • Mistrials and Double Jeopardy (Part 1)
  • Stalking and Criminal Mind State (Part 3)
  • Stalking and Criminal Mind State (Part 2)

Recent Speaking Engagement

Site Disclaimer

Attorney Referral Fees

Frederick P Sisto has earned Lawyer Legion's recognition for Community Leadership
 
Top Criminal Defense Attorney in Brick

Law Office of Frederick P. Sisto

Point Pleasant Office*:
302 Hawthorne Ave, Suite 1
Point Pleasant Beach, NJ 08742

Brick Township Office*:
223 Drum Point Road, Suite 1
Brick Township, NJ 08723

Sea Girt Office*:
2150 NJ-35,
Suite 225
Sea Girt, NJ 08750

Phone: 732-898-3232
Fax: 201-508-3393
*Office visits by appointment only.

Representing clients throughout all court jurisdictions of New Jersey.

WITH THE EXCEPTION OF THE CRIMINAL TRIAL ATTORNEY CERTIFICATION, NO ASPECT OF THIS ADVERTISEMENT HAS BEEN APPROVED BY THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW JERSEY

en English
en Englishes Spanish