Fred Sisto | Criminal Attorney | Ocean and Monmouth County

Call Us Today
732-898-3232

  • Home
  • Criminal Defense Services
    ▼
    • Drug Crimes
      ▼
      • Drug Manufacturing
      • Intent to Distribute Narcotics
      • Prescription Drug Crimes
      • Leader of Narcotics Trafficking Network
    • Weapons Charges
      ▼
      • Prohibited Weapons and Devices
      • Manufacture, Transport, etc. of Weapons
      • Illegal Possession of a Gun
      • Possession of Weapons for Unlawful Purposes
    • Expungements
    • Theft Attorney
    • Violent Crimes
      ▼
      • Robbery/Burglary
      • Manslaughter
      • Extortion
      • Assault
      • Sexual Offenses
    • Arson
    • DUI / DWI
      ▼
      • Alcohol DUI
      • Drug DUI
      • Refusing a Breath Test
    • Driving with A Suspended License
    • Property Forfeiture
    • Anti-Drug Profiteering
    • Juvenile Delinquency
  • Español / Spanish Speaking Attorney
  • About
    ▼
    • Testimonials
    • Defending Cases In
      ▼
      • Monmouth County
      • Ocean County
  • Blog
  • Contact
    ▼
    • Receive a Call From Fred
  • DUI Checkpoint Alerts
  • Results
  • Payment Options
  • Home
  • Criminal Defense Services
    • Drug Crimes
      • Drug Manufacturing
      • Intent to Distribute Narcotics
      • Prescription Drug Crimes
      • Leader of Narcotics Trafficking Network
    • Weapons Charges
      • Prohibited Weapons and Devices
      • Manufacture, Transport, etc. of Weapons
      • Illegal Possession of a Gun
      • Possession of Weapons for Unlawful Purposes
    • Expungements
    • Theft Attorney
    • Violent Crimes
      • Robbery/Burglary
      • Manslaughter
      • Extortion
      • Assault
      • Sexual Offenses
    • Arson
    • DUI / DWI
      • Alcohol DUI
      • Drug DUI
      • Refusing a Breath Test
    • Driving with A Suspended License
    • Property Forfeiture
    • Anti-Drug Profiteering
    • Juvenile Delinquency
  • Español / Spanish Speaking Attorney
  • About
    • Testimonials
    • Defending Cases In
      • Monmouth County
      • Ocean County
  • Blog
  • Contact
    • Receive a Call From Fred
  • DUI Checkpoint Alerts
  • Results
  • Payment Options
Home >> Mistrials and Double Jeopardy (Part 2)

September 25, 2023 by Fred Sisto

Mistrials and Double Jeopardy (Part 2)

The New Jersey Supreme Court continued in relevant part: Second, defendant frames the question presented as whether “prejudice to the State” can “constitute a ‘manifest necessity’ to declare a mistrial without triggering the double jeopardy bar to a re-trial.” (emphasis added.) Defendant is correct that the Appellate Division stated “once the sudden bombshell about the mistaken blood sample was revealed . . . a limiting instruction would not have sufficed to cure the massive prejudice to the State that defense counsel would surely exploit.” However, the Appellate Division did not have access to the trial transcripts, and thus was without a record of what actually happened at trial. And the “wide range of discretion” in finding a manifest necessity is recognized not in the Appellate Division, but “in the trial judge, who has his finger on the pulse of the proceedings.”

Here, the trial judge based his decision not on a concern that the State would be prejudiced by continuing with the trial, but by a desire to avoid prejudicing the defendant by forcing him to continue with a trial when the grand jury may have based its decision to indict on false testimony, and when defendant therefore may not have been indicted at all without the BAC evidence. The trial court explicitly noted that it granted a mistrial “in order to safeguard the Defendant’s rights.” (emphasis added). We have no basis to upset that finding. Like in Farmer, notwithstanding that sentence in the Appellate Division’s opinion, the trial court’s primary motive for granting the mistral “was solicitude for the defendant’s interests.”

Third, defendant contends that “allowing a retrial in this situation would allow the State to benefit from its own misconduct.” The ACDL goes further, arguing that allowing a retrial would allow the State to “adjust its own strategy and tactics” in response to defendant’s strategy during the first trial and also to fix “mistakes in jury selection, unfavorable evidentiary rulings, poor feedback from the jury, lack of witness availability, etc.”

The ACDL’s position alludes to how the conviction rate is significantly higher during retrials. This is because the State retries cases with the benefit of knowing the defense strategies. In turn, the State can thoroughly prepare their witnesses for the questions that are likely to be asked.

Filed Under: Blog, Criminal Law, Monmouth County, New Jersey, Ocean County

Testimonials

Fred is a stickler for detail and communicates with clients very, very well. He is smart and astute. I would recommend him unconditionally.

Tom O   

I would highly recommend Mr. Sisto. He is very insightful and proficient, yet still down to Earth. Fred is great at communicating and breaking down the facts. But most importantly, he excels at getting results.

Bill K   

Thanks to Fred I have no criminal record whatsoever.

Luke A   

Great!!! , got my case handled in the exact manner that I was told and would recommend to everyone else in need of legal representation.

Raumelis R   
See More Testimonials

Recent Posts

  • Lay Opinion and Harmless Error (Part 4)
  • Lay Opinion and Harmless Error (Part 3)
  • Lay Opinion and Harmless Error (Part 2)
  • Lay Opinion and Harmless Error (Part 1)
  • Trials and Foreign Language Interpretation (Part 4)
  • Trials and Foreign Language Interpretation (Part 3)
  • Trials and Foreign Language Interpretation (Part 2)
  • Trials and Foreign Language Interpretation (Part 1)

Recent Speaking Engagement

Site Disclaimer

Attorney Referral Fees

Frederick P Sisto has earned Lawyer Legion's recognition for Community Leadership
 
Top Criminal Defense Attorney in Brick

Law Office of Frederick P. Sisto

Point Pleasant Office*:
302 Hawthorne Ave, Suite 1
Point Pleasant Beach, NJ 08742

Brick Township Office*:
223 Drum Point Road, Suite 1
Brick Township, NJ 08723

Sea Girt Office*:
2150 NJ-35,
Suite 225
Sea Girt, NJ 08750

Phone: 732-898-3232
Fax: 201-508-3393
*Office visits by appointment only.

Representing clients throughout all court jurisdictions of New Jersey.

WITH THE EXCEPTION OF THE CRIMINAL TRIAL ATTORNEY CERTIFICATION, NO ASPECT OF THIS ADVERTISEMENT HAS BEEN APPROVED BY THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW JERSEY

en English
en Englishes Spanish